The Article My Mother Sent Me

Content warning: this post discusses childhood abuse, estrangement, and being disbelieved. Please take care of yourself. If you need to close this tab, close it. I mean that.

---

A few days ago I logged into a Facebook account I forgot I still had.

I made it more than a decade ago, for my pet rats, when I was a teenager. I hadn't opened it in six months. I only went looking because sometimes, if I'm honest, I still creep on my mother's page from an account she won't recognize, the way you press on a bruise to see if it still hurts.

And there it was. A message she'd sent me back in July. To the rat account. I don't know why she chose that account. But finding it there felt like discovering she'd found one more door into a room I thought I'd closed.

She'd sent me an article. A big one, the kind that went around this summer, about whether therapists are to blame for the rise of adult children going no contact with their parents. The question it asks, more or less: are some therapists too quick to validate estrangement, too willing to call ordinary hurt trauma, too ready to encourage adult children to walk away?

And above the link, she wrote:

"It's a heartbreaking, no-win situation. Grateful to see articles like this."

I want to tell you what that did to me, and then I want to tell you the truth this framing leaves out.

---

What she was really saying

I can't tell you exactly what she meant. I can only tell you what I heard, because I've been hearing versions of it my whole life.

It's a heartbreaking, no-win situation landed as: something happened to the poor mother, and the cause is conveniently offstage. There is no cause in the sentence. It simply befell her.

Grateful to see articles like this landed as: I don't believe a word you've told me. None of your experiences are real. This — a column in the Wall Street Journal — is the real version. And it's finally being represented.

She didn't just post it to her page for her friends. She sent it to me. That is not grief. That is a message. It says: I have found an authority that agrees you are deluded, and I am forwarding it to you as proof.

And here is the thing about that move. I have seen it my entire life. Deny that it happened. Then, when the person who lived it won't stop knowing what they know, recast them as the crazy one. The unstable one. The one who got talked into it.

It has a rhythm I could clap along to. I've been hearing it since I was six years old and was told the worst night of my life was a bad dream.

(If you want that part of the story, I've written it: They Don't Believe Me. This post isn't about proving what happened. It's about who gets blamed for what came after.)

---

The part the article can't survive

Here is the fact that collapses the whole premise, at least for me.

Not one of my therapists wanted me to do this. They spent years trying to talk me out of it.

I did not stumble into an office and get handed a permission slip to burn my family down. The opposite happened. Twice.

When I first told my main therapist my whole backstory — on the consult call, before we'd really even begun — his honest question was: and why do you want a relationship with them, again? He wasn't nudging me toward the door. If anything, he couldn't understand why I was still standing in it. And I was the one who said: no — I don't want to lose them. Please help me rebuild it.

That was the assignment I gave him. Save it. Fix it. Help me keep them.

And he tried. For years, he tried. He is the reason I went to the birthdays and the dinners I did not want to go to. He is the reason I stayed at the table long past the point it was good for me. When I wanted to leave, he was the voice saying: if you can have a civil relationship, have it. Try the smaller boundary first.

My other therapist — the one I saw for eighteen months, exclusively for EMDR — did the same. He discouraged no contact the entire way. And when it became clear, near the very end, that I was heading there anyway, he didn't rubber-stamp it. He gave me homework first: read Beverly Engel's Divorcing a Parent, cover to cover, before you decide anything.

So I did. I am, for the record, an audiobook girly to my core — and I sat down and read every single page of that book, because I wanted to be sure. And I came out the other side more resolute, not less. When I told him that, he was surprised. He'd expected the book to slow me down. Instead it confirmed the thing my whole body already knew. And then he said the only honest thing left to say: ultimately, it's your decision.

Sit with that. The book that was supposed to be the brake became the final confirmation. Nobody talked me into this. I got talked out of it, for years, by professionals I had asked to help me preserve the relationship — and I still, clear-eyed and entirely on my own, chose it.

So when I read an article about therapists talking adult children into abandoning their parents, I don't get angry the way you'd expect. I almost laugh. Because mine did the exact opposite. Mine were the last hands holding the door open. I am estranged from my parents despite my therapy, not because of it.

The therapist this article warns about does not exist in my story. Maybe that therapist exists in someone else's — I can't speak for them. I can only tell you, with absolute certainty, that nobody had to persuade me to leave my parents. If anything, I spent years being persuaded to keep trying.

I didn't leave people who were good to me because a therapist taught me the word boundary. I left after years of trying everything I knew how to try. It was the last thing on my list.

---

Who actually did the cutting off

I want to be precise, because precision matters here.

My mother stopped talking to me first. I invited her over. More than once. She didn't respond. My father stopped speaking to me for about six months before I ever made anything official.

By the time I "went no contact," there was almost no contact left to end. They had already gone quiet. I just stopped waiting by a phone that wasn't going to ring and said the true thing out loud: okay. This is what this is now.

That's the part the "brainwashed adult child" story cannot hold. It needs me to be the one who swung the axe at a healthy tree. But I didn't cut down a tree. I stopped watering a stump and admitted it was a stump.

I put in writing what they had already done in silence. And for that — for naming it — I became the one who did the terrible thing.

---

Nobody hypnotized me

I have to tell you the funniest, saddest detail, because it explains everything.

My mother believes therapists hypnotize you. That they put ideas in your head that weren't there. It's the reason she's always refused to go herself — she has said, out loud, that if she went, they'd convince her of things. So when I remembered what her father did to me, and when I finally chose distance to protect my own mind, she reached for the only explanation that let her off the hook: someone put it there. She was hypnotized. She isn't really choosing this.

Here is the truth, for the record.

I have tried to be hypnotized. I wanted to be. I paid good money, sat with a trained practitioner, and genuinely tried to go under. I couldn't. I can't. My brain will not let go of the wheel for anyone.

Nobody hypnotized me into my own life. I arrived at every hard thing I know the long way: through years, through EMDR, through so many tears, through a body that kept the record even when my mouth was told to stop. My memories are not implants. My decisions are not somebody else's script.

Nobody gets to be a more authoritative narrator of my interior life than I am. I was the one living it.

---

What "everything is trauma now" gets backwards

The article's real argument — the one under the therapist-blaming — is that we've gotten soft. That we call ordinary hurt "trauma." That we leave when we should stay and work it out.

I would love nothing more than to have worked it out. That is the cruel joke of it. All I ever wanted, my whole life, was: if we have an issue, let's talk it out. That's it. That's the entire ask. Hear me. Take some accountability. Don't keep hurting me on purpose going forward.

I brought that to them, plainly, more than once. I even took accountability for the things I might have done. That was never returned.

My mother has never once said you're right, I'm sorry. What she does instead is twist it — turn it, tilt it, rework the whole story — until somehow she is the wounded one and I am the one apologizing to her. I have walked into conversations to name a hurt and walked out having comforted the person who caused it. Every single time.

When I told her that her father raped me when I was six years old, she denied it. For an hour, she denied it. Then, finally, worn down, she said she believed me — not because she did, but to make me stop. To appease me and end the conversation. And the moment she was out of the room, she went and told everyone it never happened. A bad dream. That I was confused.

That is the whole machine, right there. Deny it. Perform just enough belief to quiet you down. Then recant it to the room the second your back is turned, and file you under confused so no one has to look at it again.

You cannot "work it out" with someone whose position is that there is nothing to work out. You cannot compromise with a person who was raised to believe compromise is losing. There is no smaller boundary that survives a person who won't acknowledge the boundary exists.

Estrangement wasn't me refusing to do the work. It was me finally accepting that I'd been doing all of it, alone, for thirty years, and that one side doing the work isn't a relationship. It's a job. And I quit.

---

The grief they'll never see

The article is right about one thing that matters here: there's a cost to leaving.

In that WSJ piece, the Cornell sociologist Karl Pillemer calls one cost of initiating estrangement the "exiter cost." I won't pretend I don't know that grief. I do.

But here is what I won't let anyone do with that grief.

Use my sadness as proof I was wrong.

I'm not sad because I made a mistake. I'm sad because I needed parents who could love me, and I'm never going to get them, and that is a real loss even when leaving is the right call. Both of those things are true at once. I can grieve the mother I needed and be completely, unshakably done with the mother I have. Those live together just fine.

My grief is not evidence I should go back. My grief is evidence I lost something real. Those are not the same sentence, no matter how badly a headline wants them to be.

---

The hope I'm setting down

I'll tell you the part I'm least proud of, and then I'll tell you why I'm putting it down.

Reading her message made me angrier at myself than at her. Because it meant there was still a part of me — bigger than I wanted to admit — that had been quietly hoping. That maybe one day she'd wake up. Take some accountability. Say the words. And that it wouldn't have to be forever.

I found out she's in therapy now, finally, after a lifetime of refusing. Not for any of this. For something else entirely. And for one stupid second, my chest did the thing it always does. Maybe. Maybe this is the crack of light.

And then I remembered who I was hoping about.

My therapist reflected back something I'd already started to see for myself: the hope was hurting me. Not because he told me to close the door — but because I kept noticing what happened every time I cracked it open to check. The little propped door. The bruise I keep pressing. One Facebook message and I'm six again.

I saw it. He just held up the mirror.

So I'm setting it down. Not out of bitterness — out of self-preservation. I don't need to keep checking for evidence that they've changed. I am done building my peace on a foundation of maybe someday. I am done leaving the door open just enough to keep getting hit by it.

The store is closed. I'm okay with it now. It only took me a lifetime and one Facebook notification to finally believe it.

---

If this is your story too

If you went no contact and someone has been quietly telling everyone you were brainwashed, talked into it, too sensitive, not thinking clearly — I need you to hear this in the part of you that still wobbles:

The people who broke the relationship do not get to write the story of who broke it.

You deserve to examine your own story without being told, in advance, what the conclusion has to be. Nobody gets to confiscate your experience and hand it back to you rewritten. Question it if you need to. Sit with it. Get help holding it. But you do not have to file your own memory beneath everyone else's just because they told you to — and your grief over the family you needed is not a confession that you were wrong. It's the price of the truth, and you're allowed to pay it and still be sure.

Maybe they'll send you the articles. Maybe they'll find the experts. Maybe they'll tell a version in which your reasons disappear entirely. Let them tell it. Their version does not overwrite what you lived.

You deserve to have your experience taken seriously — starting with by you.

And for whatever it's worth from a stranger on the internet who has been exactly where you are: I believe you. I'm proud of you for choosing yourself. It's the bravest thing I ever did, and I'd do it again.

---

If any part of this is your story: you deserve to be heard, taken seriously, and supported while you make sense of what you've lived.

If you need support, RAINN's National Sexual Assault Hotline is free and confidential, 24/7: call 1-800-656-4673, chat online, or text HOPE to 64673. The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline can be reached by call, text, or chat at 988. If you're LGBTQ+ and want someone who gets it, The Trevor Project is at 1-866-488-7386.

A portion of every order from Self-Care Shirts is donated to 988 and The Trevor Project.