Skip to content
4.95 stars from 234 reviews $3,860 donated to 988 + The Trevor Project Free shipping over $50 Every design drawn by hand
Cart 0
EssayNovember 17, 2026 4 min read

Complicated Gratitude: How to Be Thankful and Struggling at the Same Time

You can be grateful and still be struggling. Explore complicated gratitude, holiday grief, and gentle ways to appreciate the good without denying the hard.

Alyssa Ostroff Alyssa OstroffFounder and designer — I write these myself
Complicated Gratitude: How to Be Thankful and Struggling at the Same Time - Self-Care Shirts

Every November, the word gratitude starts showing up everywhere like it's a chore on a list. Count your blessings. Name three good things. Be thankful. And every November, some part of me braces, because I know what's coming: the quiet guilt of being handed a season of gratitude while I'm also, genuinely, struggling.

Maybe you know the feeling. You're grateful, you really are, and you're also tired, or grieving, or scared about money, or lonely in a way that gets louder this time of year. And somewhere a voice says: you have so much, what's wrong with you, just be grateful.

Here's what I want to offer you before Thanksgiving gets here: gratitude and struggle are not a contradiction. You're allowed to hold both. In fact, I think learning to hold both is one of the most honest forms of gratitude we can practice.


Forced gratitude isn't gratitude

When "be grateful" is used to shut down a hard feeling, it stops being gratitude and becomes a muzzle. Other people have it worse. At least you have a roof. Think positive. These aren't thankfulness. They're instructions to perform contentment you don't feel, and they leave you lonelier than before, because now you can't even tell the truth about how you're doing.

Real gratitude doesn't require you to be okay first. It doesn't demand you erase the hard thing to make room for the good one. It just notices the good one, too.


You can hold both in the same hand

Here's the reframe that changed Thanksgiving for me: gratitude isn't a verdict on your whole life. It's not you declaring "everything is good." It's just you noticing one true warm thing while the hard things are also still true.

I'm scared about the bills, and the way the light comes through the kitchen in the morning is beautiful. Both. I miss someone who isn't at the table, and the person who is sitting next to me is a gift. Both. The "and" is the whole trick. You don't have to resolve the tension. You just have to stop pretending only one side is allowed to be real.

This is what I call complicated gratitude. It doesn't flatten your life into a highlight reel. It makes room for the full, messy truth and still finds something to be glad about inside it.


A gentler way to practice it

If you're wondering how to practice gratitude when life is hard, and the standard "three things I'm grateful for" feels hollow when you're struggling, try these instead:

Keep it small and specific. Not "my health, my family, my home." Try "the first sip of coffee," "my dog's weight against my leg," "that one text from a friend." Small is more honest, and honest is what actually lands.

Let the gratitude and the grief sit side by side. You don't have to pick. "I'm thankful for ___, and I'm also having a hard time with ___." Say both. The second half doesn't cancel out the first. It just makes room for the whole truth.

Be grateful to yourself, too. You got through some genuinely hard days to be here. That counts. Gratitude doesn't only point outward.

Skip it when it's not working. If gratitude journaling makes you feel worse on a given day, you're allowed to close the notebook. You don't owe anyone a gratitude practice, and you don't have to find a silver lining in something that genuinely hurts. Forcing it defeats the point.


Especially heading into the holidays

The gratitude pressure peaks exactly when a lot of us are most tender. Thanksgiving tables can hold empty chairs. Family can be complicated. "What are you thankful for?" can land like a trick question when you're barely holding on.

So here's your permission slip for the season: you do not have to be more okay than you are to deserve a seat at your own life. You can be thankful and struggling. You can love the people at the table and still find the day hard. You can whisper a small, true gladness and also tell the truth about what hurts.

That's not a failure of gratitude. That's the realest gratitude there is.

If the Thanksgiving table itself is the hard part this year, I wrote a companion piece on how to survive a complicated Thanksgiving.

If this season is landing heavy, you don't have to white-knuckle it alone. You can call or text 988 anytime, free and confidential, 24/7, and our free resources hub is always open, no strings attached.


Every order at Self-Care Shirts supports the 988 Lifeline and The Trevor Project. We make gentle reminders for people holding the good and the hard at the same time — because that's most of us, most of the time.

There's a new one every Tuesday and Thursday

Tuesdays and Thursdays at 9am, like clockwork. Free to read, nothing to sign up for — same as the printables, the coloring pages and the check-in.

Explore the hub

Keep reading

All essays